The boxing world is abuzz with speculation as the iconic Floyd Mayweather considers stepping out of retirement to face Manny Pacquiao again. But is this a wise move for the undefeated champion? James Toney, a boxing legend himself, has some intriguing insights.
A Rematch Years in the Making:
The narrative begins in 2015 when Mayweather and Pacquiao finally clashed, with Mayweather claiming a decisive victory, retaining his WBC and WBA welterweight titles. Since then, the two boxers have taken divergent paths.
Mayweather, with his 50-0 record, hasn't fought professionally since 2017, opting for exhibition matches instead. But here's where it gets controversial: Is a string of exhibitions enough to keep the ring rust off?
On the other side, Pacquiao remained active, fighting at the world level until 2021. Despite a loss to Yordenis Ugas, he returned in 2025, battling Mario Barrios for the WBC title. The draw left many believing Pacquiao, even at 46, had what it takes to be champion again.
The Expert's Take:
Toney, a pound-for-pound legend, questions Mayweather's chances due to his prolonged absence from professional bouts. In an ESNEWS interview, he boldly predicts a Pacquiao victory, citing Pacquiao's enduring agility as a decisive factor.
"Manny Pacquiao has the edge, especially with his movement. It's been a decade since I've seen Mayweather in the ring." - James Toney
A Historical Context:
Interestingly, Mayweather's initial triumph over Pacquiao came when many believed Pacquiao was past his prime. Now, with both boxers potentially on the other side of their careers, a rematch could offer a unique twist to their storied rivalry.
Will Mayweather answer the call and step into the ring once more? And if he does, can he defy the odds and silence the doubters? The boxing community eagerly awaits the next chapter of this saga.
